Generally, I'm not a huge fan of the idea of suing others for accidental injuries in sports. When you decide to take part in such extracurricular activities, you assume a level of risk. It's inherent in many of the games, especially football and wrestling. In order to safeguard against this, Wisconsin law dictates that students may not sue anyone for accidental injuries while participating in "contact" sports. Tuesday, a ruling came down from the Wisconsin Supreme Court that cheerleading was included in this legislation.
Previously, the District 4 Court of Appeals had ruled that cheerleading was not a contact sport, and thus, lawsuits could be filed for accidental injuries.
Ultimately, the Supreme Court got it right here, but not because of how they defined cheerleading. As I insinuated in the first paragraph, it's ridiculous to sue a teammate for accidentally causing an injury when you already knew the risks involved in this activity. Cheerleading nowadays contains so many different stunts, mistakes are bound to happen. If you are too scared to suffer an injury due to human error, don't be a cheerleader. With all due sensitivity to anyone whose been injured doing so, everyone should know this going in.
On the other hand, calling cheerleading a contact sport is really ridiculous. Yes, I know it's a strenuous activity. So is marching in the school band. So is running cross country. This doesn't make something a contact sport. Injuries in contact sports are due to the violent nature of the sport itself, while injuries in cheerleading are due to teammates' dropping each other or not being strong enough to continue a stunt.
This isn't a knock on cheerleading. Not in the least. I played high school baseball, and that's definitely not a contact sport. It's not like playing a contact sport is some sort of a badge of honor which separates it from all other sports (I also played football, and I don't take any more pride in one sport than the other).
The issue at hand here should be the law, and how it is written. Why are the restrictions only placed on so-called "contact" sports. Why did the school district have to prove cheerleading was a contact sport in order to protect itself? Are you gonna tell me that when a baseball player slides into a base, and accidentally breaks an opposing player's ankle, that the injured player can sue the slider because baseball is not a contact sport? That's downright laughable. Let us exercise some common sense here.
Enough with the lawsuits. Make players sign a waiver that the only way they can sue anyone over an injury is through blatant neglect -- dangerous equipment left around the playing surface, for example -- or through intentionally malicious actions. Sure, they'll have to prove either case, but that's the point of having a legal system.
Society's already litigious enough, without having numerous high school athlete cases where someone suffered a freak injury.











Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
1-28-2009 @ 10:49AM
horatiowrd said...
actually they ruled that a contact sport is any sport where there is "physical contact between persons" which would mean your baseball example would fall under it. While basketball may not be a "BIG" contact sport you still have guys going up and coming down on each other and you need this immunity or someone will be sued when they rolled an ankle.
Reply
1-28-2009 @ 3:03PM
apnsdean said...
I remember many years ago when Bill Russell was asked if basketball was a "contact sport", like football. He answered that basketball was definitely a "contact sport"...................
But football was a "collision sport".
Reply
1-29-2009 @ 12:20PM
Sharon McEachern said...
Oh cheerleading is a contact sport alright! For young women in both high school and college, two-thirds of all severe sports injuries (from 1982 to 2007) were related to cheerleading, according to the National Center for Catastrophic Sport Injury Research. Read the national center's guidelines to help prevent cheerleading injuries at:
http://www.ethicsoup.com/guidelines-to-help-prevent-cheerleading-injuries.html
Reply
2-09-2009 @ 6:52PM
Lauren said...
i totally disagree. I live in wisconsin and i am on a competitve cheerleading team. We work harder than most of the average sports. Girls train year round just for 2 minutes and 30 seconds to show off their skills. An in the end, they recieve not even half the credit other athletes recieve. Cheerleaders have to condition and take multilple tumbling and dance classes to keep up with their skill level. In new studies cheerleading has been declared the most dangerous sport. Girls or Boys are getting hurt each day just to do waht they love. Cheerleading teaches respect, perserverance, honesty, and many other valuable life skills. It bothers me so much when people underestimate cheerleaders. They have no idea how hard they work and have no right to judge them. Hopefully someday this will change.
Reply